Tag: Rights

Introduction:

Thomas Paine emerged from a background marked by relative lack of success, having encountered failure in numerous pursuits during his early life. He exhibited strong support for the American Revolution, notably more so than Edmund Burke, as demonstrated by his seminal work Common Sense (published in 1776), which was disseminated among American troops engaged in combat against the British. Furthermore, his subsequent publication The Rights of Man (published in 1791) galvanized a generation of liberals by endeavoring to “expose the fraud and imposition of monarchy.” Paine was resolutely opposed to ritual and tradition for their own sake, perceiving monarchy as a parasitic entity that drains resources from the general populace.

The Common Sense:

Thomas Paine’s Common Sense, published in January 1776, was a groundbreaking pamphlet that played a pivotal role in galvanizing public support for American independence. By its publication, tensions between the American colonies and Britain had escalated, particularly following events like the Boston Massacre in 1770 and the Boston Tea Party in 1773. In clear and articulate prose, Paine argued against monarchy and hereditary succession, advocating instead for a democratic republic. He emphasized the natural rights of individuals, the importance of self-governance, and the detrimental effects of British rule on the American colonies, highlighting that over 25,000 British troops were stationed in America by 1776. Paine’s work combined Enlightenment ideals with practical political theory, effectively appealing to the colonists’ sense of justice and reason, and selling over 500,000 copies in just a few months. By addressing both the emotional and rational aspects of political discourse, Common Sense inspired widespread revolutionary sentiment, culminating in the Declaration of Independence on July 4, 1776, and ultimately influencing the course of American history while challenging the established order of governance.

The Rights of Man:

Thomas Paine’s Rights of Man, published in two parts in 1791 and 1792, emerged as a seminal text in the discourse of intellectual history, advocating for the principles of democracy and individual rights during a period of revolutionary fervor in Europe and America. This work was a direct response to Edmund Burke’s conservative critique in Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790), and it championed the notion that government should be a product of the people’s will rather than a divine or hereditary imposition. Paine argued for universal suffrage and the inherent rights of individuals, positing that all men are born equal, a radical assertion for its time, echoing the sentiments of the Enlightenment. His ideas contributed to the political landscape that would inform the creation of democratic governments, influencing revolutions such as the French Revolution in 1789 and the broader struggle for human rights that gained momentum in the 18th and 19th centuries, marking a significant evolution in the concept of citizenship and governance.

Of those who argued for gradual reform, Paine saw them as a condescending elite who “pities the plumage, but forgets the dying bird.” That is to say, they wished to improve the lives of the worst somewhat, whilst fundamentally leaving them in the same position as they were before. The way he wrote chimed with a working class who could look up and see the ‘bird’ flying free above them, whilst they were stuck with the cruel realities of working life in London. He goes on to say that:

“Men should not petition for rights, but take them.”

Therefore, the people should be judged by what they achieve in their rebellious politics, and radicals should not accept the maintenance of the status quo. Tradition for Paine is nonsense, and it should not be blindly accepted, as he pens, “Reason obeys itself; ignorance submits to whatever is dictated to it.” From this standpoint, Paine believed that society needed to be based and built around the core Enlightenment notion of reason, and that one should only obey a social contract when one sees a reason why one should do so.

The Age of Reason:

Now the ‘Age of Reason’ had arrived, and so too had the Age of Reason by Thomas Paine in 1794. Paine (1736-1809) had been an interesting Enlightenment thinker from elsewhere in Enlightenment Britain to Edinburgh. He had been born into a Quaker family, which shaped his liberal attitudes towards the age’s new shifts in thought. In fact, much of the said text was written in prison in Paris after being incarcerated as an enemy of the revolution, after having left his native England (on a tip-off from his friend, poet William Blake) for being considered by Pitt too far supportive of the French Revolution in 1789. But what is so interesting about this text is that it encapsulates the complexities of the era; it argues in support of Enlightenment tropes such as reason over the irrational, but also reinforces a belief in the divine against the established church.

Just like other scholars such as Voltaire, Paine saw established religion as corrupt but certainly didn’t reject religion per se. Reason, for him, brought humans to the conclusion that there is a deity and rejected the miracles and mysticism of religious teachings of the past. Therefore, we can see the non-secular elements of this transformative age revealing themselves. Moreover, Paine had been in dialogue earlier with Jefferson about his drafting of the Declaration of Independence (1776), and this reveals where the American thinkers would pick up certain Enlightenment themes of liberty, religious toleration, and the use of reason.

By way of conclusion:

The liberal social contract would be extended after Paine’s time through the Great Reform Act of 1832 (middle-class males), the Reform Act of 1867 (16% of the overall electorate), the Reform Act of 1884 (nearly all male citizens), and finally to women in 1918. This was realistically very slow reform, but the life and thought of Paine set in motion a turn toward reason over ritual, and ideals over ignorance.

Bibliography:

• Burke, Edmund. Reflections on the Revolution in France. London: J. Dodsley, 1790.
• Paine, Thomas. Common Sense. Philadelphia: W. and T. Bradford, 1776.
  • Rights of Man. Philadelphia: William Cobbett, 1793.
  • The Age of Reason: Being an Investigation of True and Fabulous Theology. New York: Thomas H. Huxley, 1794.